April 2011 - RTC-Web - alvestrand.no

Fwd: W3C mailing-list [was Re: Updated W3C draft charter for Web RTC WG]
by Harald Alvestrand 12 Apr '11

12 Apr '11

This is to be the official public list of the (still in-formation) W3C WG for WebRTC. Welcome! Harald -------- Original Message -------- Subject: W3C mailing-list [was Re: Updated W3C draft charter for Web RTC WG] Date: Tue, 12 Apr 2011 08:48:09 +0200 From: Francois Daoust <fd(a)w3.org> To: Harald Alvestrand <harald(a)alvestrand.no> Hi Harald, The public-webrtc(a)w3.org mailing-list is up and running. To subscribe to the mailing-list, one needs to send an email to public-webrtc-request(a)w3.org with subject "subscribe", or click on the "subscribe to this list" option on the archives page. The archives are available at: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-webrtc/ Francois. On 04/07/2011 11:27 AM, Francois Daoust wrote: > On 04/07/2011 10:50 AM, Harald Alvestrand wrote: >> Francios, >> >> a) waiting for anything from me? > > No, I'm waiting for replies from reviewers to my own replies [1] before I can get back to W3C management with a disposition of comments to ask for their formal approval of the changes and chairs nomination. > > David Baron's already replied that he's ok with the proposed changes, so I'm waiting for Chaals feedback in particular. Not a big deal if we don't hear back from other reviewers. > > >> b) are things firm enough that we can create a public-webrtc-whatever(a)w3.org mailing list and start using it for API discussions? > > That's usually done when the group gets created, but we can certainly do that before, yes. I've just requested the creation of a public-webrtc(a)w3.org mailing-list. It may take a few days for this request to be processed by the systems team. > > Francois. > > [1] http://www.w3.org/Search/Mail/Member/search?keywords=daoust&hdr-1-name=subj… > >> >> Harald >> >> On 04/04/11 11:11, Francois Daoust wrote: >>> Hi Harald, >>> >>> It took some time for lack of time and connection last week, but I've eventually made a few changes to the W3C draft charter for Web RTC. See latest version at: >>> http://www.w3.org/2010/12/webrtc-charter.html >>> >>> The diff is available at: >>> http://www.w3.org/2007/10/htmldiff?doc1=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.w3.org%2F2010%2F12… >>> >>> List of changes: >>> - liaison with Web and TV IG (for home networking scenarios) added >>> - "any new" added to the mention that audio and video codecs are out of scope to respond to Art Barstow's comment, as that seemed benign enough. >>> - milestones section completed. Let me know if you have comments on this initial roadmap. I've merged all functions into one single row to keep things simple. >>> - decision policy copied from HTML charter >>> - deliverables section completed to put more emphasis on collaboration with IETF without mandating any specific text, using similar wording as that of the latest IETF RTCWeb group's charter. >>> >>> (Note the diff tool loses itself near the end: only the decision policy section has been changed) >>> >>> I stayed silent on the relation with WHATWG, and also did not introduce any change in the charter to address Stefan's detailed comments (e.g. "There must be support for media format negotiation and selection in the solution") to leave that as discussion for the group. >>> >>> Could you review the changes and let me know whether that looks good for you? >>> I've read the BoF notes taken by Christer Holmberg. Any other input from the IETF BoF meeting that would trigger additional changes in the charter? >>> >>> If you're fine with the changes, I'll get back to reviewers to get their approval, and to W3C Management with a disposition of comments to have them approve the charter and the WG chairs. Depending on the time it take to get reviewers approval, the decision could be taken this week, next week or the week after that (on Wednesday, each time). The group's creation can be officially announced shortly after that. >>> >>> Do you have a timeline for the creation of the IETF group? Having both groups created at the same time might be good if that's not too much of a pain to do. >>> >>> Dan Burnett proposed himself as co-chair for the Web RTC group. Dan has a good experience of W3C groups and is already chair of the Voice Browser working group and of the HTML Speech Incubator Group. On the minus side, he already has quite a few W3C activities on his plate. I do not know well Dan and Stefan. It doesn't make sense to have 3 chairs for the group. Do you have a strong preference? >>> >>> Who would be the chairs of the IETF working group? >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Francois. >>> >> >>

2 2

Audio recordings of sessions
by Harald Alvestrand 08 Apr '11

08 Apr '11

Here are the links: http://ietf80streaming.dnsalias.net/ietf80/ietf80-ch3-tues-am.mp3 and probably: http://ietf80streaming.dnsalias.net/ietf80/ietf80-ch5-fri-pm.mp3 but the session does not start at the beginning, and my Linux tools fail to seek... Harald

2 2

Updated mailing list; please re-subscribe
by Ted Hardie 05 Apr '11

05 Apr '11

In case you are not on the DISPATCH mailing list, our AD recently posted this: Subject: RTCWeb mailing list Date: Tue, 05 Apr 2011 10:57:07 +0300 From: Gonzalo Camarillo <Gonzalo.Camarillo(a)ericsson.com> To: DISPATCH <dispatch(a)ietf.org> Hi, FYI: as part of the chartering process, we have created the following mailing list: http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/rtcweb/current/msg00001.html This mailing list is intended to be the mailing list of the RTCWeb WG-to-be. From now on, RTCWeb-related discussions should happen on the newly-created list. Note that the RTCWeb charter is still under IESG/IAB review. Cheers, Gonzalo *Pleae subscribe to the new list and continue discussion there.* * * *Thanks,* * * *Ted*

1 0

Fwd: Updated Charter for RTCWeb
by Harald Alvestrand 02 Apr '11

02 Apr '11

The revised charter, incorporating what we were able to remember from the BOF. This has now been sent to the IESG for their one-week review. Harald

3 3

Ad-hoc RTCWEB meeting (Fwd: [dispatch] DISPATCH Ad-HOC meetings about VIPR and RTCWeb at IETF 80)
by Harald Alvestrand 01 Apr '11

01 Apr '11

Friday 1415-1515 in the Grand Ballroom. -------- Original Message -------- Subject: [dispatch] DISPATCH Ad-HOC meetings about VIPR and RTCWeb at IETF 80 Date: Tue, 15 Mar 2011 11:45:13 -0600 From: Cullen Jennings <fluffy(a)cisco.com> To: DISPATCH list <dispatch(a)ietf.org> The dispatch WG will have two ad-hoc meeting. The first is discuss the technical content of the drafts related to the proposed VIPR WG. Tentative time: VIPR's is in Tyrolka on Thursday 1300-1400 The second is to discuss the technical contents of drafts related to the proposed RTCWeb WG. Tentative time: RTCWeb's is Friday 1415-1515 in the Grand Ballroom Send Agenda requests for time in either of these to Mary and I. Thanks, Mary& Cullen _______________________________________________ dispatch mailing list dispatch(a)ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dispatch

2 1